· 5 min
San Diego approves Midway Rising; Sacramento backs Railyards district expansion
San Diego's City Council approved the Midway Rising deal for the Sports Arena site, Sacramento's City Council voted to approve expanding the Railyards financing district, and Los Angeles County supervisors asked the Sheriff's Department to identify and name deputy gangs.
Download the MP3 · 4.7 MB
This episode is made with AI from each government's own show, which reports from the public recordings of its meetings. Sources are in the show notes.
Transcript
Headlines
00:00
Maya This is California in 5, from CivicFM: the week at the city halls and county boards we cover.
Maya San Diego's City Council approved the Midway Rising deal for the Sports Arena site, Sacramento's City Council voted to approve expanding the Railyards financing district, and Los Angeles County supervisors asked the Sheriff to name deputy gangs.
“San Diego's City Council approved the Midway Rising deal for the Sports Arena…” San Diego 00:43:25 Sacramento 02:50:31 LA County 03:27:22
In the notes: Midway Rising: lease deal for the Sports Arena site and its environmental review
Maya This episode is made with AI from each government's own show, which reports from the public recordings of its meetings. Sources are in the show notes.
Read more: Midway Rising: lease deal for the Sports Arena site and its environmental review · Railyards infrastructure financing district expansion · Identifying and naming deputy gangs in the Sheriff's Department
Cold open
00:44
Theo No episode this week from Bakersfield.
Top story: San Diego council approves Midway Rising Sports Arena deal
00:49
Maya Our top story: San Diego's City Council on Monday approved Midway Rising, the plan to rebuild the city-owned Sports Arena site. City staff described a four point two billion dollar project with up to forty-two hundred fifty-four homes, two thousand of them affordable, plus a new arena and parks. It passed eight to nothing, with Marni von Wilpert absent, along with a first step toward a district that would repay the developer for public infrastructure out of future property tax growth.
“Our top story: San Diego's City Council on Monday approved Midway Rising, the…” San Diego 00:43:25
“City staff described a four point two billion dollar project with up to…” San Diego 00:43:25
“It passed eight to nothing, with Marni von Wilpert absent, along with a first…” San Diego 07:18:17 San Diego 00:43:25
In the notes: Midway Rising: lease deal for the Sports Arena site and its environmental review
Theo The Independent Budget Analyst's office called it a reasonable balance of risk and return, but warned that three-quarters of arena ticket fees reach the city only if the developer hits a target return. The zoning was only introduced, and the unfinished affordable housing lease must come back.
“The Independent Budget Analyst's office called it a reasonable balance of risk…” San Diego 01:33:04 San Diego 01:37:30 In the notes
“The zoning was only introduced, and the unfinished affordable housing lease…” San Diego 00:43:25 In the notes
Read more: Midway Rising: lease deal for the Sports Arena site and its environmental review · Midway Rising tax-increment financing district · Midway Rising land use approvals: plan amendment, rezone, specific plan and development agreement
Top story: Sacramento council approves Railyards district expansion, 8-0
01:39
Theo Next, Sacramento, where the City Council voted eight to nothing Tuesday, with Caity Maple absent, to approve expanding the Railyards financing district, part of a deal tied to Sacramento Republic's soccer stadium. A share of future property tax growth there pays back infrastructure, and the affordable housing set-aside would rise from twenty to twenty-five percent of the district's net revenue.
“Next, Sacramento, where the City Council voted eight to nothing Tuesday, with…” Sacramento 06:02:40 Sacramento 02:50:31
“A share of future property tax growth there pays back infrastructure, and the…” Sacramento 06:02:40 Sacramento 02:50:31
In the notes: Railyards infrastructure financing district expansion
Maya Speakers were split. Here's one urging delay, a member of the public, on that set-aside.
“Speakers were split.” Sacramento 02:50:31
In the notes: Railyards infrastructure financing district expansion
A member of the public (from the meeting) I want to be really clear. That is not the same thing as 25% affordable housing that we have been calling for. It is a small step in the right direction, but it is not enough. It would only be 25 of the revenue left over after developers have been reimbursed.
Sacramento 03:45:12
Theo The expansion now goes to the district's financing authority on December first.
“The expansion now goes to the district's financing authority on December first.” Sacramento 03:24:34
In the notes: Railyards infrastructure financing district expansion
Read more: Railyards infrastructure financing district expansion
Top story: LA County board asks Sheriff to identify and name deputy gangs
02:31
Maya Our last top story: Los Angeles County's Board of Supervisors on Tuesday asked the Sheriff's Department to set criteria for identifying deputy gangs and cliques, and to name them publicly without requiring criminal charges. All five supervisors voted yes. The motion also calls for a review of every station, jail and unit within a hundred eighty days, and a ban on racist symbols.
“Our last top story: Los Angeles County's Board of Supervisors on Tuesday asked…” LA County 01:25:12
“All five supervisors voted yes.” LA County 03:27:22
“The motion also calls for a review of every station, jail and unit within a…” LA County 01:25:12
In the notes: Identifying and naming deputy gangs in the Sheriff's Department
Theo Sheriff Robert Luna said he was committed to eradicating deputy gangs, but that it had to be done legally, focusing first on behavior. A county report found only the racist-symbols ban had to be bargained with deputy unions before taking effect. The Sheriff's first report is due in sixty days.
“Sheriff Robert Luna said he was committed to eradicating deputy gangs, but that…” LA County 01:32:24
“A county report found only the racist-symbols ban had to be bargained with…” LA County 01:25:12
In the notes: Identifying and naming deputy gangs in the Sheriff's Department
Read more: Identifying and naming deputy gangs in the Sheriff's Department
Around the state
03:17
Theo Now a quick trip around the state. Fresno's City Council on Thursday adopted a policy restricting federal immigration enforcement on city property. It also approved renewing its project labor agreement, with union terms on city projects above two point seven five million dollars, less than the three and a half million the mayor urged. Both passed six to one, with Nick Richardson opposed, and are subject to the mayor's veto.
“Fresno's City Council on Thursday adopted a policy restricting federal…” Fresno 01:36:24 In the notes
“It also approved renewing its project labor agreement, with union terms on city…” Fresno 01:36:24 In the notes
“Both passed six to one, with Nick Richardson opposed, and are subject to the…” Fresno 03:33:04 Fresno 01:36:24 In the notes
Maya Oakland's City Council on Tuesday extended its moratorium on approving data centers by ten and a half months, eight to nothing, while staff drafts rules on where they could go, with limits on power, water and air quality.
“Oakland's City Council on Tuesday extended its moratorium on approving data…” Oakland 01:32:20 Oakland 00:07:58
In the notes: Data center moratorium: 35-day report and ten-month extension
Theo In October we told you San Jose's City Council asked for a list of flood hotspots. On Tuesday, city staff said a joint plan with Valley Water identifies fifty-nine, and the council unanimously proclaimed a local emergency ahead of El Niño storms.
“On Tuesday, city staff said a joint plan with Valley Water identifies…” San Jose 00:44:04 San Jose 01:29:25
In the notes: El Niño flood preparedness and local emergency proclamation
Maya And on Tuesday, Anaheim's City Council approved, seven to nothing, a twenty-year deal to buy all the power from a solar and battery plant in Fresno County, about nine hundred fifty-five million dollars over the term, paid by utility ratepayers. Staff said it wouldn't change bills in the near term.
“And on Tuesday, Anaheim's City Council approved, seven to nothing, a…” Anaheim 03:40:17 Anaheim 03:19:22
“Staff said it wouldn't change bills in the near term.” Anaheim 03:19:22
In the notes: 20-year solar-plus-battery power purchase from Heartland Solar 1
Read more: Policy restricting federal immigration enforcement on city property · Project Labor Agreement renewal: threshold set at $2.75 million · Data center moratorium: 35-day report and ten-month extension · El Niño flood preparedness and local emergency proclamation · 20-year solar-plus-battery power purchase from Heartland Solar 1
Sign-off
04:33
Maya That's the week around California. See you next time.
The stories
From this week's episodes of San Diego, Fresno, Sacramento, Bay Area in 5, San Francisco, Oakland, San Jose, LA Area in 5, Anaheim, Burbank, LA County, Pasadena, Long Beach and Los Angeles.
San Diego · City Council Monday, November 9
3 items
San Diego's episode · The recording · Agenda
Midway Rising: lease deal for the Sports Arena site and its environmental review Item 602
Development projectsAffordable housingHousing supply
The core real-estate deal for redeveloping the city-owned Sports Arena site at 3500, 3250, 3220 and 3240 Sports Arena Boulevard in District 2. Subitem A certifies the project's Subsequent Environmental Impact Report (No. 1106734/SCH No. 2023120451), with findings, a statement of overriding considerations and a mitigation monitoring program. Subitem B approves a Disposition and Development Agreement (DDA) ground-leasing the land to Midway Rising LLC, makes related findings, and waives Council Policy 700-10 (agenda). Staff described a roughly $4.2 billion project: up to 4,254 homes, 2,000 of them affordable at an average of no more than 60% of area median income, a 16,000-seat arena replacing the current one, 130,000 square feet of retail, and about 14.5 acres of parks and public space. The city keeps ownership; vertical ground leases run 85 years. City revenue comes from ground and participation rent on market-rate housing and retail and a per-ticket arena fee that starts in year 11; no rent is charged on the affordable housing sites. The review found some impacts that can't be fully mitigated. 00:43:25
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) moved the staff recommendation (certify the SEIR and approve the DDA) with amendments offered by Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council), shown on screen and in a handout, giving the city a share of net refinancing proceeds; Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council) seconded and Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) accepted the amendments; Marni von Wilpert (Councilmember, District 5) was absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 07:18:17
- The Economic Development Department said the developer must build 2,000 affordable units on site averaging no more than 60% of area median income 00:46:48
- The Economic Development Department said the $4.2 billion project does not pencil out without an enhanced infrastructure financing district, with the developer taking on the upfront risk 00:48:48
- The Economic Development Department said that since committee, staff added language barring the site from becoming an affordable-housing receiver site until all other financing options are exhausted 00:53:59
- The Economic Development Department explained that once the developer's initial equity is repaid, the city gets 0.5% of modified gross revenue from market-rate housing and retail through year 55, rising to 2.5% after 00:58:13
- The Economic Development Department said arena ticket-fee rent is waived for the first ten years and starts in year eleven, escalating 3% a year 00:58:13
- The Economic Development Department said the city will not charge rent for the affordable housing pad sites or share in their sale proceeds 01:00:18
- The Economic Development Department projected total ground rent over the life of the leases at almost $900 million in nominal dollars, not counting sale proceeds or the ticket fees held behind the return hurdle 01:04:34
- City staff said that even with mitigation, impacts on land use, transportation, historical and tribal cultural resources and noise remain significant and unavoidable 01:28:44
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office estimated city revenues over the century-long agreements at $884 million to $1.2 billion, worth about $38 million to $69 million in present value at a 4.5% discount rate 01:31:58
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office concluded that the agreement is a reasonable balance of risk, financial return and public benefit for the city 01:33:04
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office cautioned that 75% of arena ticket fees accrue behind a 16.5% levered return hurdle, and the city would not collect them if the developer or later owners never reach it 01:37:30
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office said an IBA report estimated roughly 200 to 800 affordable units elsewhere in the city that could be eligible to shift to Midway Rising, but only with city approval 01:40:39
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office flagged falling tax-credit pricing and stiffer competition for state affordable-housing grants as a risk to financing every affordable phase 01:41:39
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office noted the city would commit nearly 50 acres of public land for roughly a century, limiting future alternative uses of the site 01:43:39
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office said the developer had agreed to DDA changes letting the city share in future net refinancing proceeds, which would need to be added in the council's final action 01:44:41
- A councilmember asked staff what is being done about access into the neighborhood from the rest of the city, citing constituents' worries about getting in and out of Point Loma 05:58:24
- City staff said the project will build a roundabout at Hancock and Kurtz and widen Hancock Street from two lanes to four 06:00:16
- A councilmember asked the developer whether claims made in public comment were true, including that the first homes would take ten years 06:02:21
- A Midway Rising representative said this was untrue and that affordable and market-rate housing are phased to be delivered together 06:03:23
- A councilmember said the updated DDA generally bars using the project's affordable units to satisfy other developments' obligations, with a narrow exception requiring city approval at its sole discretion and state housing department confirmation 06:10:40
- A councilmember offered amendments giving the city 5% of net refinancing proceeds above a 19% return, rising to 10% on later refinancings above a higher threshold 06:11:44
- A councilmember acknowledged the financing, construction and market risks but said supporting the package means weighing them against the benefits 06:14:47
- A councilmember agreed with the IBA that the deal is a reasonable and fair transaction given the city's goals, citing housing affordability 06:15:28
- A councilmember asked development staff why the transit improvements are scheduled for phase two rather than phase one, as the Planning Commission and many speakers urged 06:17:37
- City staff said phase one includes existing bus routes, partial transit lanes, free private shuttles and a multi-use path to Old Town, which staff found sufficient for demand at that stage 06:18:12
- City staff said building hard transit improvements on the west side early would create throwaway work, since that area is developed in later phases 06:22:06
- City staff said conditions were written to allow for MTS's planned rapid Route 210, which may not arrive until 2035 06:23:15
- A councilmember said four councilmembers sit on the MTS board and he looks forward to continuing the conversation on getting transit improvements in place for the arena's opening 06:24:12
- A councilmember praised staff and the developer and called the project a vast improvement for the area 06:24:57
- The council president said the program matches what the council chose four years ago, recalling a pledge to withdraw support if there were a bait and switch 06:28:11
- The council president noted the parks are privately built and maintained but must be open to the public daily 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., and asked special-events staff to limit closures 06:31:10
- The council president disputed public claims that the site is in a flood plain 06:34:38
- The council president said it was a missed opportunity not to have the project contribute to upgrading the undersized storm water Pump Station H, though no amendment was offered 06:36:08
- City staff said, for the city's engineers, that all building floor elevations would sit above the most conservative state sea level rise projections 06:38:18
- City staff said the council approves the DDA and the forms of its attachments, except the affordable housing ground lease form, which was not finished and must come back 06:43:55
- City staff said the city's protections stay the same whether the build-out is fast or slow, and it gets revenue sooner if the developer moves faster 06:45:37
- City staff said groundbreaking can't happen until the horizontal ground lease closes and the DDA's performance triggers are met 06:46:45
- The council president predicted the project will spur redevelopment of the surrounding area, likening it to Horton Plaza and Petco Park 06:48:06
- The City Attorney's office said the affordable housing lease form is a condition of the horizontal ground lease, so the project can't proceed if the council rejects it 06:50:23
- The City Attorney's office said state law SB 344 sets affordability levels but no deadline for building the units 06:53:14
- A councilmember asked about section 15.3.6, which lets the developer delay some affordable units if gap financing can't be secured 06:59:52
- The Economic Development Department said that delay is allowed only in phases two or three 07:00:36
- The Economic Development Department explained that 1,063 units cited in a state letter is the Surplus Land Act minimum, but the developer is held to its 2,000-unit promise 07:04:54
- A Midway Rising representative said, for the affordable-housing developer, that it no longer uses subcontractors with compliance defaults and the project is subject to a project labor agreement 07:06:32
- A councilmember noted voting against selecting this developer in 2022 and said the city could have gotten a better financial deal 07:07:55
- A councilmember apologized to residents who questioned the project and said they had been mocked and belittled by leaders 07:08:57
- A councilmember criticized how the city negotiates land deals, arguing that signaling it would never walk away weakened its position 07:10:06
- A councilmember asked that the development team report back every year to a council committee on progress 07:16:18
Midway Rising tax-increment financing district Item 600
Bonds and debtDevelopment projects
Two resolutions: one declaring the city's intention to form the Midway Rising Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District (EIFD), and one creating its Public Financing Authority, the district's governing board (agenda). An EIFD cannot raise taxes. It redirects future growth in property tax inside the district, in this case 100% of the city's and county's shares for about 45 years, to repay the developer for public infrastructure it builds up front, such as streets, storm drains, utilities, parks and public portions of garages. That money would otherwise go to the city and county general funds. Staff projected about $1.2 billion in combined contributions, about 52% of it from the city; staff put the total at $148 million in today's dollars at a 6% discount rate; eligible costs were estimated at $370 million, or about $462 million with capital maintenance. The board would have seven members: two councilmembers, two county supervisors and three members of the public. Formation is not final until an infrastructure financing plan is approved by the city, the county and the authority, which staff expected in fiscal year 2028. 00:43:25
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) moved the staff recommendation on item 600, seconded by Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council); Marni von Wilpert (Councilmember, District 5) was absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 07:19:08
- The Department of Finance explained that the district can't create or change taxes and instead captures future growth in property tax revenue 01:08:59
- The Department of Finance described a seven-member financing authority of two councilmembers, two county supervisors and three public members 01:09:59
- The Department of Finance said the district would be funded by 100% of the city's and county's shares of property tax growth 01:09:59
- The Department of Finance projected combined contributions of about $1.2 billion, about 52% from the city, and roughly $985 million available after bond debt service 01:13:07
- The Department of Finance put eligible costs at about $370 million initially and about $462 million including capital maintenance, excluding the developer's carrying costs 01:14:07
- The Department of Finance said it would take the district its full life to repay the developer, and projected revenues support at most a 3% annual carrying cost 01:15:08
- The Department of Finance said the resolution sets the first public hearing on the infrastructure financing plan for August 27, 2027 01:16:09
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office said about $370 million, roughly 80% of the project's infrastructure costs, could be reimbursed by the district 01:34:15
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office noted tax increment grows very slowly in the first fifteen years and likely won't pick up until after 2045 01:35:18
- A councilmember urged that staff quantify neighborhood infrastructure gaps, such as a new fire station, and make them eligible in the financing plan 06:10:40
- The council president asked whether the council will get to weigh in before the financing district is docketed for final approval 06:29:16
- City staff confirmed the council will have that opportunity 06:29:59
- The Department of Finance said storm water and flood-prevention work can generally be reimbursed if it has a tangible connection to the project 06:54:09
- The Department of Finance said that if the district can't repay infrastructure costs, the shortfall falls on the developer 06:55:09
Midway Rising land use approvals: plan amendment, rezone, specific plan and development agreement Item 601
Zoning and plansDevelopment projectsHistoric preservation
The land use package for the project (PRJ-1106734). It amends the General Plan and the Midway-Pacific Highway Community Plan, adopts the Midway Rising Specific Plan with signage exceptions, rezones 49.23 acres from CC-3-6 to the residential mixed-use RMX-2 zone, removes the site from the Community Plan Implementation Overlay Zone, adopts a development agreement, grants a variance to the inclusionary housing rules, creates a Midway Rising Entertainment Center District in the Municipal Code, and approves a vesting tentative map with easement vacations and a site development permit (agenda). The ordinances were introductions, and none of the subitems is subject to the Mayor's veto (agenda). Staff said allowed density rises from 44 to up to 72 homes per acre. The 30-year development agreement lists extraordinary benefits valued at $1.2 billion, including up to $2.5 million for Fire Station 20 upgrades. The site development permit is needed because the project demolishes the Sports Arena, a designated historic resource. The community planning group voted 7-0 and the Planning Commission 6-0 to recommend approval. The commission recommended putting the transit improvements in phase one; staff did not include that change. 00:43:25
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) moved the staff recommendation on item 601, seconded by Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council), with two amendments shown on screen: Joe LaCava (Councilmember, District 1; President, City Council)'s, removing the district identity pylon in the public right-of-way from the specific plan, Appendix B and Figure 44; and Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7)'s, adding a $2 million extraordinary-benefit payment to the development agreement for transportation improvements in the community planning area, due at the arena's final inspection or certificate of occupancy; Marni von Wilpert (Councilmember, District 5) was absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 07:37:20
- City staff said, for Development Services, that the specific plan allows 4,254 homes, 2,000 of them affordable 01:18:11
- City staff said the community plan amendment raises allowed density to up to 72 homes per acre and repeals the overlay zone on the site 01:20:16
- City staff said the development agreement locks in development rules for thirty years in exchange for public benefits beyond standard requirements 01:25:29
- City staff said the benefits include an extra fee of up to $2.5 million for Fire Station 20 upgrades 01:26:30
- City staff said the site development permit is needed because the project demolishes the historic Sports Arena 01:26:30
- City staff said the area is not mapped in a FEMA special flood hazard area, though the shallow storm drain system has caused flooding 01:27:37
- City staff said the Planning Commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval with one recommendation, to put transit improvements in phase one 01:28:44
- City staff said staff did not include or recommend that change, citing too few homes in phase one and MTS's control over bus service 01:29:46
- The council president said the allowance for 250-foot buildings on 10% of the site surprised him and was not shown in the renderings 06:30:08
- The council president said he disliked the tower allowance but did not expect to have the votes to strike it 06:31:10
- The council president raised concerns about 50-foot sign pylons with moving images, citing distraction, bird impacts and the 30-foot height limit 06:38:37
- City staff said, for Development Services, that the pylon proposed in the public right-of-way is not allowed under current law 06:39:39
- A councilmember asked the developer to pay $2 million for traffic signal modernization to ease travel in and out of Point Loma, paid before the arena's building permit 06:57:24
- A Midway Rising representative agreed to an additional $2 million payment for traffic congestion relief in the Midway District 06:58:32
- The council president proposed removing the right-of-way pylon from the specific plan so it doesn't confuse future reviewers 07:19:08
- A councilmember asked whether a sign at the roundabout would create traffic problems 07:22:05
- A councilmember asked what traffic improvements the $2 million could cover, mentioning interest in transit signal priority 07:25:36
- A councilmember said the goal is to synchronize traffic signals so traffic flows 07:25:50
- City staff cautioned that whatever the money funds must be analyzed under state law, including environmental law 07:26:59
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office asked about the payment's timing, noting staff described it as due around the arena's final inspection 07:27:23
- A councilmember said writing the signal work into the amendment would be improper, so the Mayor's office was asked for an on-record commitment instead 07:35:48
- City staff confirmed the $2 million is an extraordinary-benefit payment under the development agreement, not tied to the DDA or its return hurdles 07:36:39
- City staff said the payment would be collected by City Planning 07:36:54
Fresno · City Council Thursday, November 12
2 items
Fresno's episode · The recording · Agenda
Project Labor Agreement renewal: threshold set at $2.75 million Item 2-B
Jobs and wagesContracts and purchasingStreets and public works
An amendment to the city's Project Labor Agreement with the building trades for city public works projects, sponsored by the administration with Nelson Esparza (Councilmember, District 7; Council President), Tyler Maxwell (Councilmember, District 4; Council Vice President) and Annalisa Perea (Councilmember, District 1). Under the agreement, union labor terms apply to city projects above a contract-value threshold. The current threshold is $1 million, and the administration negotiated $3.5 million with no escalator for another five years. Other negotiated changes: residents of county islands count as local hires, and the city-resident apprentice goal is set at 50%. The council approved it on consent with the threshold amended from the dais to $2,750,000. The item is subject to the mayor's veto, and the mayor urged the council to keep the negotiated $3.5 million. 01:36:24
- A councilmember moved to approve the consent calendar with 2B amended to a $2,250,000 threshold (later offering $2,500,000); the seconder withdrew. Result: withdrawn. 03:22:07
- A councilmember moved to approve the consent calendar, excluding contested items, with item 2B amended to a $2,750,000 project threshold. Result: passed, 6-1. No: Nick Richardson (Councilmember, District 6). 03:33:04
- A councilmember proposed an amendment raising the threshold from $1,000,000 to $2,250,000 instead of the negotiated amount 01:36:38
- A councilmember said any change from what was negotiated would have to go back for approval and could return at the next meeting 01:37:41
- A councilmember asked for the rationale, noting the council had earlier sent the administration back to negotiate and was now renegotiating the number from the dais 01:39:05
- A councilmember thanked the building trades, credited labor for his election, and predicted the council would split the difference 02:56:53
- A councilmember rejected a caller's claim that the agreement amounts to wage theft 02:56:53
- An elected official said the administration spent a year negotiating a $3.5 million threshold with no escalator, the trades voted to approve it, and it should not be reopened from the dais 03:05:43
- An elected official said he would not want the agreement modified at the dais 03:05:43
- City staff said the $3.5 million figure came from data on the 59 projects covered so far, whose average contract was about $4.79 million 03:10:41
- City staff said the trades won counting county-island residents as city residents in exchange 03:11:41
- City staff urged the council to keep the $3.5 million threshold reached in good-faith negotiation 03:13:48
- A councilmember offered $2,750,000 as a compromise figure 03:15:13
- A councilmember said the staff report gives no rationale for any of the changes 03:16:55
- A councilmember argued that going from $1 million to $3.5 million is a 250% increase that inflation cannot explain 03:17:57
- A councilmember argued that a higher threshold means fewer city jobs for local union members, and offered $2.5 million 03:19:14
- A councilmember asked for a public commitment to support a veto override in exchange for the lower figure 03:20:44
- A councilmember withdrew the second from the $2.25 million motion 03:22:02
- A councilmember said he supports $2.75 million but is not guaranteeing a vote to override a veto 03:23:00
- A councilmember said he had asked the administration to count county-island residents as local hires, which was accepted 03:24:30
- A councilmember said he had asked the administration for a $2.5 million threshold 03:25:38
- A councilmember cited a left-turn signal project at Millbrook and Alluvial that cost about $400,000 years ago and now costs about $1.2 million 03:25:38
- A councilmember argued the agreement lacks consequences if local-hire and apprenticeship goals are missed 03:28:41
- City staff asked whether any amendment must also be agreed to by the building trades, and noted nods from the city attorneys 03:31:46
Policy restricting federal immigration enforcement on city property Item 2-T
Immigrants
A resolution sponsored by Annalisa Perea (Councilmember, District 1) and Nelson Esparza (Councilmember, District 7; Council President) that sets a policy restricting the use of city-owned or city-controlled property for federal civil immigration enforcement. It is a resolution, not an ordinance, and its sponsor said it states the council's intent, with implementation to be worked out with the city manager and city attorney. It passed in the consent vote; it is subject to the mayor's veto. 01:36:24
- A councilmember moved to approve the consent calendar, excluding contested items, with item 2B amended (2T approved as posted). Result: passed, 6-1. No: Nick Richardson (Councilmember, District 6). 03:33:04
- A councilmember said attendance at his district's community events dropped after federal immigration enforcement intensified in 2025, and hoped for a unanimous vote 02:54:37
- A councilmember said supporting the resolution was easy for him 02:55:44
- An elected official said police policy bars officers from immigration enforcement and from asking about status, and that the city does not share information with ICE 02:58:18
- An elected official said he raised concerns about ICE tactics in a call with the White House and the Department of Homeland Security that Tuesday 02:59:19
- An elected official asked what the consequences would be if ICE uses city property anyway 03:00:20
- A councilmember said the resolution states intent rather than law, and that implementation details, including consequences, will be worked out with the city manager and city attorney 03:00:48
- An elected official said armed police should not be expected to confront armed ICE agents, though putting the federal government on notice was understandable 03:02:06
- Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) called the item somewhat symbolic but said it sets the tone 03:07:13
- Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) said enforcement should focus on violent criminals rather than working people 03:08:18
- A councilmember said he voted no because moving the item back to consent removed the chance to add recording and reporting provisions 03:31:12
Sacramento · City Council Tuesday, November 10
1 item
Sacramento's episode · The recording · Agenda
Railyards infrastructure financing district expansion Item 29
Economic developmentBonds and debtAffordable housing
Expands the Railyards Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District to add the Railyards West area and amends its infrastructure financing plan, letting a share of future property tax growth there repay infrastructure such as streets, utilities, parks and open space; the set-aside for affordable housing rises from 20% to 25% of net district revenues. Staff described it as a continuation of the 2024 term sheet and the 2025 comprehensive project agreement among the city, the Railyards master developer and Sacramento Republic FC, whose 20,000-seat stadium is under construction; the master developer's chief executive called the expansion the agreement's final major step. Staff projected over $180 million for affordable housing over the district's life; Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) and speakers urging delay said that money comes last, after others are paid. The 2016 development agreement's affordable-unit floor, cited as 6%, is unchanged. Dozens of speakers split between support and calls to delay for a community benefits agreement. 02:50:31
▶ Hear it Is a 25% set-aside the same as 25% affordable housing? · 0:15
- Kevin McCarty (Mayor) moved to adopt the resolution expanding the Railyards EIFD and amending the infrastructure financing plan, including raising the affordable housing set-aside from 20% to 25% of net EIFD revenues, with direction to staff to work with the landowners on increased local investment and partnerships and return to council; seconded by Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7). A first vote was announced 8-0; Mai Vang (Councilmember, District 8) then said she would vote no without a timeline for staff to report back, Maraskeshia Smith (City Manager) offered a report-back around the end of January, and the vote was retaken; Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 06:02:40
- City staff said the deal brings more than $325 million in upfront private investment and could support over 13,000 jobs. 02:53:28
- City staff said nearly 500 Railyards units have been built so far, 44% of them deed-restricted affordable. 02:53:28
- City staff said the district is expected to generate over $180 million for affordable housing with the 25% set-aside. 02:53:28
- The city's financing consultant presented the city's fiscal analysis estimating a general fund surplus of about $362,000 a year in the initial phase and about $3.4 million a year at build-out. 02:57:55
- The city's financing consultant said the city's commitment would draw about $95 million more in private infrastructure spending, which developers advance and bear the risk on. 02:59:00
- The Railyards master developer's chief executive said the developer has built 495 units, 219 of them affordable, and is entitling a 300-unit project. 03:01:40
- Wilton Rancheria's chairman said the tribe kept investing in the stadium during delays and asked the city to keep its commitment. 03:20:10
- City staff said that if approved, the expansion goes next to the Railyards EIFD public financing authority on December 1. 03:24:34
- City staff said the financing plan does not fund a parking garage; a 1,200-stall garage is only a land-use assumption and a footnote leaves it open for study, with no amount committed. 04:48:48
- City staff explained the 6% figure comes from the 2016 development agreement and is a variable floor tied to total units. 04:50:42
- City staff said the 6% refers to a share of housing units while the 25% refers to a share of district revenues, so the two are not comparable. 04:52:39
- The Railyards master developer's chief executive said housing demand should rise once the anchor projects open, but construction timing depends on the market. 04:55:39
- The mayor argued the deal has no impact on the general fund because it relies on future tax growth in the district. 04:57:26
- The mayor asked staff, the developer, Wilton and the Republic to keep working on local investment and good-paying union jobs, outside the motion. 04:59:48
- Phil Pluckebaum (Councilmember, District 4) argued that saying no is the easy, safe choice and that the project itself is the community benefit. 05:00:26
- A councilmember said he sympathizes with calls for more affordable housing, local hire and labor representation but cannot attach them to an already negotiated deal tonight. 05:08:45
- A councilmember asked for ways to deliver affordable housing money sooner than the late 2030s. 05:09:46
- A councilmember objected that the new district boundary drew out existing residents who had been inside it, which staff confirmed. 05:11:46
- A councilmember called for a Railyards for everyone, not just the wealthy, with union jobs. 05:12:47
- A councilmember said the deal should include a community benefits agreement like Aggie Square's. 05:17:00
- Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) argued affordable housing money arriving twenty years from now, after others are paid, is not enough, and that the deal could be better. 05:19:05
- Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) said she would vote for the district expansion because she believes in the soccer project. 05:20:07
- Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) asked the developer why housing cannot be built now. 05:22:13
- The Railyards master developer's chief executive answered that the urban rental market is soft because so much housing was recently built. 05:22:33
- Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) asked staff to bring a list of potential partners for added community benefits to the December 1 financing authority meeting. 05:26:16
- Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) asked whether anything in the specific plan prevents negotiating more affordable housing; staff said no, the 2016 strategy sets a floor. 05:29:31
- City staff confirmed the mixed-income strategy sets only a floor for affordable housing. 05:30:29
- Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) suggested a mobile fresh food market, costing about $10,000 a year, for residents in the food desert until a store opens. 05:34:15
- City staff committed to meeting with Railyards residents at least once a year. 05:35:49
- Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) said the council should not use its power on the Railyards vote as retribution for not getting what one wants in another city. 05:39:19
- The city manager noted the new state affordable housing bond as a tool the city could pair with district revenue. 05:40:28
- Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) said Aggie Square's benefits came from steady negotiation, not imposition. 05:42:10
- Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) pointed to the staff report's revenue projections showing little district revenue until about project year 11. 05:43:10
- Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) asked the developer and Wilton Rancheria to commit to working with the mayor's office on a local hiring and local investment plan. 05:45:12
- The Railyards master developer's chief executive said the developer is open to talks on local hiring but not ready to commit to metrics or zip codes. 05:48:17
- Wilton Rancheria's chairman committed the tribe to sitting down to discuss local hiring. 05:49:54
- The mayor floated, outside the motion, prioritizing Railyards projects for state housing bond money and keeping housing trust fund fees generated there in the Railyards. 05:57:00
- The city manager said staff would talk with the partners and report back, but a December timeline was not realistic. 06:00:34
- A councilmember said she would vote no without a timeline for staff to report back; after a report-back at the end of January was agreed, the vote was retaken. 06:01:38
Oakland · City Council Tuesday, November 10
1 item
Oakland's episode · The recording · Agenda
Data center moratorium: 35-day report and ten-month extension Item 4.1
Zoning and plansPollutionEnergy
The council had adopted a 45-day emergency moratorium (Interim Emergency Ordinance No. 13899 C.M.S.) on approving any land use entitlements or agreements for developing or operating data centers in Oakland. Staff said it was adopted October 6 and would expire November 20. State law (Government Code 65858(d)) requires a written report within 35 days on steps taken; the council held a public hearing on that report and on an emergency ordinance (file 27-0178) extending the moratorium for ten months and fifteen days, which under the City Charter could be adopted the same day but needed seven votes. Staff said the extension would carry the work through October 5, 2027, while it drafts zoning rules covering where data centers could go and limits on power, water and air quality. 00:07:58
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to open the public hearing. Result: passed, 8-0. 00:08:20
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to close the public hearing and adopt both pieces of legislation: the resolution issuing the 35-day report, and the emergency ordinance extending the data center moratorium for ten months and fifteen days. Result: passed, 8-0. 01:32:20
- City staff explained that state law requires a 35-day report on the work done under the 45-day moratorium 00:10:16
- City staff said the 45-day moratorium was adopted October 6 and expires November 20 00:11:20
- City staff cited other cities with data center moratoriums, including San Francisco, Gilroy, Oakley, El Monte and Richmond, and said Richmond adopted a 22.5-month extension 00:13:26
- City staff said staff is consulting utilities and regulators, including PG&E and the air quality district, with particular concern about backup generators 00:16:34
- City staff said the city plans to hire outside consultants because of the expertise this facility type requires 00:17:37
- City staff asked for the ten-month, fifteen-day extension allowed by state law, saying it would carry the work through October 5, 2027 00:19:43
- A councilmember said two major tech companies have leased space in West Oakland and another has shown interest in a downtown site 00:20:38
- A councilmember said the moratorium is not a rejection of technology or economic growth but guardrails on the industry 00:21:39
- A councilmember objected to companies requiring officials and landlords to sign nondisclosure agreements, which keeps the public uninformed 00:22:44
- A councilmember cited public health data showing West Oakland life expectancy six to seven and a half years below the county average 00:23:46
- A councilmember asked staff for a list of land and properties available for development in Oakland 00:26:32
- A councilmember said the city pays to lease space for police and public works, citing $4 million a year near the Coliseum, while public land goes unused 00:27:33
- The council president asked staff to send the council a supplemental list of properties that might be available 00:28:28
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked which city departments will help with the regulatory research 00:29:08
- City staff named economic development, race and equity, and information technology, plus public works and transportation 00:29:44
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked for an implementation timeline, such as choosing consultants within 90 days 00:30:43
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked for a report back within 30 days on the community engagement plan, regulatory research and consultant procurement 00:32:03
- City staff offered to set up regular updates with the department 00:32:26
- City staff said the project website should be updated before the end of the year 00:33:08
- A councilmember urged that the definition of a data center not end up restricting light manufacturing and industrial uses 00:33:19
- A councilmember said massive GPU farms have no place in Oakland 00:33:19
- A councilmember suggested the threshold could rest on wattage, water use, power use or square footage 00:34:22
- City staff said staff is also considering a place-based approach, allowing some facilities in some areas and not others 00:34:39
- A councilmember thanked a community group that surveyed more than 400 West Oakland residents and shared its data 00:35:18
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said cannabis operations in his district haven't been monitored, and asked who will enforce the moratorium and regulations 00:39:13
- City staff said Planning and Building will lead enforcement and may lean on other departments such as fire 00:40:05
San Jose · City Council Tuesday, November 10
1 item
San Jose's episode · The recording · Agenda · Agenda
El Niño flood preparedness and local emergency proclamation Item 3.3
Emergency preparednessStreets and public works
A joint city and Valley Water report on preparing for a forecast, potentially historic El Niño storm season, and a resolution proclaiming a local emergency under Chapter 8.08 of the Municipal Code to match the Governor's state of emergency and organize city resources (agenda). Staff said the proclamation lets the city move faster on acquiring emergency equipment and resources and that they will return every 60 days on whether to keep it in place. 00:37:31
- Rosemary Kamei (Councilmember, District 1) moved to accept the report and adopt the resolution proclaiming a local emergency under Chapter 8.08; seconded (seconder not identified). Result: passed, unanimous. 01:29:25
- The environmental services director warned that much of San Jose's creek system is natural channel without engineered levees and can overflow in heavy or prolonged rain. 00:37:31
- The environmental services director urged all residents to sign up for county emergency alerts, noting you don't have to live by a creek to be flooded. 00:38:31
- The environmental services director explained that the storm drain system is built for a once-in-ten-year rain, so street flooding in bigger storms is expected. 00:39:41
- City staff said the joint plan identifies 59 flood hotspots from past experience, but flooding can happen elsewhere too. 00:44:04
- City staff added that the transportation department monitors 22 more locations. 00:45:04
- City staff described four response levels (preparedness, monitoring, watch, warning) tied to how full the creeks are, with creeks currently under 50% at the lowest level. 00:46:06
- The environmental services director said Upper Penitencia Creek can only carry a two-year storm and has no federal funding for improvements. 00:48:04
- A guest presenter said the second phase of Valley Water's Coyote Creek project will be done by 2028, giving roughly the capacity of the 2017 flood event. 00:49:55
- A guest presenter said the federal Upper Guadalupe River project is years away, with a chief's report around 2031 or 2032, so Valley Water is pursuing interim protection. 00:50:57
- A guest presenter reported about 167 stream maintenance projects this season, about 126 of them vegetation removal and bank stabilization. 00:53:08
- A guest presenter said there are five county sandbag sites, three of them in San Jose, with webcams showing supply. 00:57:07
- A guest presenter reminded residents that flood insurance takes 30 days to take effect, so it must be bought before the rain. 00:58:13
- City staff reported 63 new CERT graduates since July and nearly 100 registered for the December course. 00:59:50
- City staff said the emergency proclamation lets the city acquire and place emergency equipment and resources. 00:59:50
- City staff said staff would return to the council every 60 days on whether to keep or end the local emergency. 01:00:54
- Rosemary Kamei (Councilmember, District 1) asked whether the agencies are seeking permit waivers to clear the worst debris blockages this year. 01:06:39
- A guest presenter said a second governor's proclamation waived many state Fish and Wildlife permits, but state water board permits are still required. 01:07:23
- A guest presenter said San Jose is seeking emergency permits for some of the worst locations along Coyote Creek. 01:08:24
- Rosemary Kamei (Councilmember, District 1) urged a joint push to get the worst sites cleared before the storms, then moved the recommendation. 01:08:55
- A councilmember promoted a Friday walk along the Guadalupe River with Anthony Tordillos (Councilmember, District 3), a Valley Water board member, and an engineer about El Niño preparedness. 01:10:43
- Domingo Candelas (Councilmember, District 8) asked for sandbag sites closer to outlying districts, such as community centers or libraries, after hearing concerns at a mobile home park near Thompson Creek. 01:13:46
- A guest presenter said Valley Water would coordinate with the city on additional or smaller sandbag sites. 01:15:04
- Anthony Tordillos (Councilmember, District 3) praised the Coyote Mudlarks' advocacy and the agencies' efforts with state and regional water boards to streamline debris removal. 01:16:09
- A guest presenter said the Upper Penitencia project runs from I-680 to just past King Road, and Valley Water hopes to use exemptions for sediment removal next year. 01:17:58
- David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) faulted Valley Water for delaying the long-planned King Road Bridge widening and urged combining it with the creek work. 01:19:43
- The mayor asked that information sessions target neighborhoods nearest the hotspots of greatest concern. 01:20:36
- A guest presenter said Valley Water is hanging about 48,000 door hangers and running a media campaign, including movie and streaming ads. 01:21:26
- The environmental services director said two webinars are planned on Valley Water's flood-ready map. 01:22:28
- The mayor asked how well the agencies can monitor, verify, and alert residents in real time across about 60 hotspots. 01:23:58
- A guest presenter said Valley Water is confident in its monitoring and keeps a staffed 24-hour line for reporting blockages. 01:24:39
- City staff said field crews log conditions with photos on internal dashboards, partly to document the emergency for federal reimbursement. 01:26:31
- City staff described outreach to unhoused people along creeks, including multilingual broadcasts from police vehicles. 01:27:58
Anaheim · City Council Tuesday, November 10
1 item
Anaheim's episode · The recording · Agenda
20-year solar-plus-battery power purchase from Heartland Solar 1 Item 7
EnergyContracts and purchasingClimate and sustainability
Anaheim Public Utilities will buy all output from a 150 MW solar and 138.5 MW battery facility in Fresno County for 20 years, at an annual average cost of $47,700,000 and about $955,000,000 over the term (agenda). Staff called it the largest project in the utility's portfolio, enough for roughly 75,000 Anaheim homes, and said it helps meet state mandates of 60% renewable power by 2030. It is paid by utility ratepayers, not the general fund; staff said it would not change bills in the near term. 03:19:22
- Motion to approve the Renewable Energy Purchase and Storage Agreement with Heartland Solar 1, LLC (mover and seconder not identified). Result: passed, 7-0. 03:40:17
- The acting Public Utilities General Manager said the project helps meet the state mandate of 60% renewable power by 2030. 03:19:36
- The acting Public Utilities General Manager said a 2025 request for proposals drew 85 offers from 28 developers. 03:20:36
- The acting Public Utilities General Manager said the plant will sit on 2,362 acres of retired farmland about 30 miles southwest of Fresno, away from high-risk fire zones and schools. 03:20:36
- The acting Public Utilities General Manager said it would power roughly 75,000 homes, with construction starting March 2027 and operation by summer 2028. 03:21:39
- The acting Public Utilities General Manager put the fixed-price cost at about $47 million a year, about $23 million for solar and $24 million for storage. 03:21:39
- The acting Public Utilities General Manager explained the battery stores cheap midday solar power for use in the evening when demand and prices rise. 03:22:41
- A council member noted the aggregate cost of more than $900 million over 20 years and asked how Anaheim compares with other utilities. 03:23:55
- The acting Public Utilities General Manager said Anaheim is on track to meet the 60% renewable requirement while some others are not quite there yet. 03:24:25
- A council member confirmed with staff that the cost comes from the utility's ratepayer-funded enterprise fund, not the general fund. 03:24:54
- Public Utilities' assistant general manager of finance and energy resources said customers would see no change in reliability and the batteries would discharge at peak evening demand. 03:25:28
- Natalie Rubalcava (Council Member, District 3) praised the utility and said residents avoid brownouts seen in cities served by Edison. 03:26:27
- A council member asked whether the clean energy is also cheap and whether ratepayers would pay more. 03:27:26
- Public Utilities' assistant general manager of finance and energy resources said customers' bills would not change in the immediate future because of the project, since a Utah power plant goes offline in June 2027 and this replaces it in the budget. 03:28:05
- Public Utilities' assistant general manager of finance and energy resources said the power supply budget is about $310 million a year and not expected to change materially in the next couple of years. 03:28:05
- Public Utilities' assistant general manager of finance and energy resources cautioned that future variable costs such as transmission can't be predicted. 03:28:41
- Public Utilities' assistant general manager of finance and energy resources said the plant's expected capacity factor is about 32%, with the battery adding about four hours a day. 03:29:27
- Public Utilities' assistant general manager of finance and energy resources acknowledged a gas plant would likely be cheaper absent state rules, but new gas plants can't be built in California. 03:30:22
- Public Utilities' assistant general manager of finance and energy resources explained that the city gets no renewable credit for its Hoover Dam share because state law excludes large hydropower. 03:31:25
- A council member asked about environmental and fire risks of the battery facility. 03:32:11
- The acting Public Utilities General Manager said Fresno County's environmental review considered fire hazard and flooding and approved the project. 03:32:42
- Public Utilities' assistant general manager of finance and energy resources described performance guarantees: no payment for the battery if it falls below 90% of capacity for three straight months, and price differentials if solar falls below 80%. 03:33:38
- Public Utilities' assistant general manager of finance and energy resources said the city would receive $350,000 per megawatt in liquidated damages if the project misses its completion date. 03:33:38
- The acting Public Utilities General Manager said the city owns no part of the plant, so equipment failures are the owner's responsibility. 03:34:52
- Public Utilities' assistant general manager of finance and energy resources said state waivers exist if the 60% target is missed, requiring council authorization, but staff has no intention of seeking one. 03:35:35
- A council member voiced frustration with state mandates that leave the city carrying nearly a billion dollars in long-term obligation. 03:36:07
- Natalie Rubalcava (Council Member, District 3) asked whether the state might roll back or extend the mandates under the new governor. 03:37:01
- The acting Public Utilities General Manager said staff has seen no indication of a policy shift and continues to plan for electrification and load growth. 03:37:28
- Natalie Rubalcava (Council Member, District 3) asked staff to consider lobbying Sacramento to relax the clean energy mandates. 03:38:01
- The presiding officer asked, and staff confirmed, that the city is not building the plant, only buying its output for 20 years. 03:38:30
- Public Utilities' assistant general manager of finance and energy resources said Anaheim is the sole buyer of the plant's power, though the contract could be assigned to partner agencies. 03:39:10
- Public Utilities' assistant general manager of finance and energy resources said an approximately 18-megawatt landfill power project leaves the portfolio in 2036. 03:39:53
LA County · Board of Supervisors Tuesday, November 10
1 item
LA County's episode · The recording · Agenda · Supplemental
Identifying and naming deputy gangs in the Sheriff's Department Item 13
Police oversightPolicingPublic employees
A motion by Holly Mitchell (Supervisor, Second District; Chair Pro Tem), split and continued from September 15, asks the Sheriff's Department, with County Counsel's office and the oversight agencies, to set criteria for identifying deputy gangs, cliques and secret subgroups and to publicly name them without requiring criminal charges. It also asks for a confidential list to the board, a review of all stations, jails and units in 180 days, a 60-day report on the Office of Constitutional Policing, a public online complaint system, an Inspector General inventory of unofficial insignia in Sheriff's facilities within 90 days, a departmentwide ban on racist symbols, and reports on outside investigations, ways to cut deputy-gang lawsuit payouts, and the board's enforcement options. A Chief Executive Office report found only the racist-symbols ban needs bargaining with deputy unions before it takes effect. 01:25:12
- Holly Mitchell (Supervisor, Second District; Chair Pro Tem) moved approval of item 13 as corrected; the seconder is not clear; all five members voted aye in the roll call. Result: passed. 03:27:22
- Holly Mitchell (Supervisor, Second District; Chair Pro Tem) said the motion has been in print for two more months since September, ample time to review it 01:27:00
- Holly Mitchell (Supervisor, Second District; Chair Pro Tem) said the motion does not presume every deputy is a gang member or presume individual guilt 01:29:05
- Holly Mitchell (Supervisor, Second District; Chair Pro Tem) called a process for identifying deputy gangs by name one of the most important elements 01:29:05
- Holly Mitchell (Supervisor, Second District; Chair Pro Tem) argued deputies should get no more benefit of the doubt about gang affiliation than alleged street gang members 01:30:06
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) pledged commitment to eradicating deputy gangs but said it must be done legally, focusing first on behavior, then on any names or tattoos associated with it 01:32:24
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) said anyone can already file a complaint through the department's website and five other ways, including through the Inspector General 01:34:30
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) said new deputies sign a pledge that joining a law enforcement gang will get them fired 01:36:32
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) cited reductions in use of force and a 22.8 percent drop in deputy shootings on a five-year average 01:38:43
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) announced the department reached agreement with labor the previous Wednesday on a new clique policy 01:39:45
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) said a new enhanced field training officer program starts January 2027 01:39:45
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) said 22 of 26 applicable Civilian Oversight Commission recommendations are now substantially met, two partially 01:42:54
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) said the department will not implement two recommendations: ending the rank structure and mandatory rotation of deputies 01:42:54
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) said related lawsuits fell from 19 in 2020 to two last year and none this year 01:44:02
- Holly Mitchell (Supervisor, Second District; Chair Pro Tem) countered that, in her experience, complaints from residents have not fallen and people still report retaliation 01:45:26
- Holly Mitchell (Supervisor, Second District; Chair Pro Tem) disputed that reporting is easy for people afraid for their lives 01:46:28
- Holly Mitchell (Supervisor, Second District; Chair Pro Tem) summarized the Chief Executive Office report: only the racist-symbols ban requires bargaining first; other parts depend on implementation or need none 01:47:35
- Janice Hahn (Supervisor, Fourth District) said she sought the split so staff could report which directives need bargaining, and only the racist-symbols directive does 01:49:53
- Janice Hahn (Supervisor, Fourth District) said she was surprised removing racist, homophobic and white supremacist symbols requires bargaining 01:50:54
- The Chief Executive Officer explained that new policies affecting working conditions must be bargained 01:51:28
- The Chief Executive Officer said the board can adopt the directive now and the county would bargain before implementing it 01:51:28
- County staff said bargaining would center on the discipline attached to violating the ban, which does not currently exist as policy 01:52:58
- Janice Hahn (Supervisor, Fourth District) cited Measure R subpoena power, approved by voters in 2020 and still in bargaining, and a tattoo policy in bargaining since 2023 01:53:29
- Janice Hahn (Supervisor, Fourth District) said she wants to explore a time limit on the meet-and-confer process 01:54:29
- The Chief Executive Officer said the law sets no time limit on bargaining and imposing one could bring an unfair labor practice charge, so legislation may be needed 01:55:41
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) said the new clique policy is effective immediately and will go out through department training 02:00:22
- Kathryn Barger (Supervisor, Fifth District) asked whether the county can declare an impasse to bring in a mediator 02:03:03
- Kathryn Barger (Supervisor, Fifth District) asked for a review of why Measure R bargaining has taken six years and how many sessions have been held 02:04:33
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) reported that by the end of September 2026 there were 47 supervisor inquiries into deputy gangs and cliques: 32 closed (20 referred to Internal Affairs, 12 needing no further action) and 15 pending 02:08:02
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) said discipline in several cases has gone as far as dismissal 02:08:02
- Kathryn Barger (Supervisor, Fifth District) asked how to break the logjam so the Civilian Oversight Commission can do its oversight job 02:09:43
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) said the department has never refused the commission and only insists on following the bargaining process 02:15:25
- Lindsey Horvath (Supervisor, Third District) said she supports the motion and that implementation, not effort, has fallen short 02:19:24
- Hilda Solis (Supervisor, First District; Chair) recalled authoring a 2019 motion that led to a study of secret deputy subgroups 02:20:01
- The Sheriff said bargaining priorities have been use of force, then deputy gangs, then cliques, with grooming and tattoo policies next 02:25:22
- Robert Luna (Sheriff) said the department will report on enforcement as transparently as the law allows 02:29:41
- The Sheriff said the deputy gang policy took effect around September 2024 and does not name gangs because the law focuses on behavior 02:32:19
- Holly Mitchell (Supervisor, Second District; Chair Pro Tem) argued naming a group lets patterns of behavior be connected under it 02:32:53